Didn't Do It · 31 August 2026 · 4 min read

Position clues, and why they feel different

Lees in het Nederlands

Most clues describe the culprit's name. A few describe where the culprit is standing. They are the fastest clues in the game to apply and the easiest to apply to the wrong grid.

A grid of twenty cards with one row and one column markedPOSITION CLUES READ OFF THE LAYOUTclue“Not in the same row” and “not in the same column” remove a band each; together they clear a cross.

Three clues about geometry

A grid of twenty cards with one row and one column markedPOSITION CLUES READ OFF THE LAYOUTclue“Not in the same row” and “not in the same column” remove a band each; together they clear a cross.
The grid is five cards wide. A row clue and a column clue together clear a cross through the layout.

Why they are so fast

You do not read a single name to apply them. You find the referenced card, look along its row or down its column, and strike. On a grid of a hundred a row clue removes four names in about a second, and a column clue removes nineteen.

That asymmetry is worth remembering: on a tall grid, column clues are enormously more powerful than row clues, because the grid is always five wide and however many rows deep.

The one thing to be careful about

Next to means horizontally adjacent within a row. The card above and the card below are not next to anything — they are in the same column. A name at the end of a row is not next to the name at the start of the next row either, even though they look adjacent when the grid wraps.

If a position clue ever seems to eliminate the culprit, check whether you are counting wrap-around neighbours. That is the mistake nine times out of ten.

They do not survive a reshuffle

Position clues are the only clue type tied to a particular layout rather than to the names themselves. Replay a free-play rung and the grid is dealt fresh, so any position clue you memorised is meaningless — which is exactly why a replayed level is a genuinely new puzzle rather than a memory test. More on that in daily dossiers and free play.

Find a case with position clues

Related reading